Philly Cheesesteak Sloppy Joes Sandwich Recipe (2024)

Follow Six Sisters’ Stuff onInstagram|Facebook|Pinterest|YouTube

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1. Jenn says:

   This does sound like a great alternative. I can't wait to try it.

2. tracypoh says:

   Hi there,

   I am following you back. Thanks for the follow!

3. Phil and Darby Hawley says:

   This looks so delicious!

4. Janet says:

   Oh My Word! I'm writing a dinner list for the DREADED grocery shopping today, and this one's going on my list!! YUMMMM!!!

   www.iheartmygluegun.com

5. Margaret says:

   Can't wait to try this one.

6. Susan says:

   My family agrees that this is our new go-to sloppy joe recipe. Thanks!

7. chandler-breeze says:

   how many does the recipe yield?

8. teresa says:

   This looks excellent! I love Philly Cheesesteaks. Was wondering about the steak sauce, what kind do you use? I am pretty unfamiliar with them and would like to know what to buy. Thanks! p.s. I am trying the crockpot refried beans today!

9. Six Sisters says:

   @Teresa,

   I just use A1 Steak Sauce or the generic brand of it!

10. Six Sisters says:

    @chandler-breeze,

    This would serve 6-8 people.

11. Unknown says:

    I just made this tonight - it took a recipe that is an old standard and made it sexy. Thanks -delicious!

12. Candice & George says:

    I tripled the recipe for my family!! It tasted great! Only modification I would change for next time is to use less broth. I drained about a cup from the pot before I served it. Other than that, I wouldn't change a thing!! Thanks for sharing!!

13. Anne Marie says:

    I made these last weekend, and it was sooooo goooooood!! Thanks for the recipe!

14. Anna says:

    Just made these and they were so yummy! My fiancé suggested adding teriyaki because that's what they do at Penn Station. Do this! A tablespoon or two of teriyaki really made a difference! Yum!

15. Tonya says:

    My family loved this! Thank you!

16. rileyk says:

    Anyone used ground chicken or turkey instead of ground beef?

17. Najla5cents says:

    We made this tonight with ground turkey and it was yummy! We added more steak sauce and melted the provolone in with the meat and veggies. We will definitely make this again!

18. http://livingatthewhiteheadszoo.blogspot.com/ says:

    Can't wait to try this. I just added it to my May menu & linked back to you. Yummy.

19. bhoop says:

    Did you use the teriyaki instead of the steak sauce? Or both? That sounds pretty tasty as well! Thanks for the tip!

20. {northern cottage} says:

    mmmmmmmmmmmmmm - did I say mmmmmmm? and how!! fab recipe share - I've pinned as one of my new fav finds - thanks so much for sharing!! xo http://pinterest.com/pin/56787645271944180/

    and you can connect with me direct here:

    http://www.northerncottage.net/
    http://pinterest.com/northernc/

21. {northern cottage} says:

    making these for dinner tonight I think! sounds yummy & something the whole family would like! thanks for sharing this great idea

22. CraftyLilBrat says:

    We LOVED these! I actually found a 4-cheese blend from Land O Lakes at the deli counter - an Italian blend. SO GOOD! Will be making these instead of Manwich from now on.

    See Also

    Cider-Glazed Chicken with Browned Butter-Pecan Rice Recipe

23. Melanie Nelson says:

    Tried this Sat. night for the football game dinner. It was fantastic!!! Thanks so much.

24. Judy says:

    Looks great!Stupid question--after you brown the beef I'm assuming you drain the fat?

25. The Ellis' says:

    Hi Judy!

    That isn't stupid at all! Yes, drain the fat after you brown the beef. Thanks for the questions!

    Elyse (one of the sisters)

26. whiterose512 says:

    I'm making these for the 2nd time tonight. We loved this recipe. Easy and the kids (and adults) loved them! Thank you!

27. Alison says:

    Had these twice so far! Yummy!

28. MaryBeth says:

    This comment has been removed by the author.

29. MaryBeth says:

    Making these babies tonight! Thanks for sharing the recipe. I also shared your recipe on my blog and credited you.
    xoxoMB

    http://occupationmnhousewife.blogspot.com/2013/02/monday-night-meal-planning.html

30. lovefam6 says:

    Would it change the taste to mince the mushrooms, onion, and green pepper to better hide them in the meat? I wouldn't think it would, but as soon as I assume something... we all know that saying.

31. Six Sisters says:

    I would think you could chop them finer to better hide it in the meat! :) Thanks for stopping by our blog! -The Six Sisters

32. lovefam6 says:

    I think I did mine wrong. Was the broth supposed to cook into the meat, b/c mine is just soupy looking =(

33. Six Sisters says:

    I have never had a problem with it being overly soupy. If you feel like there is too much liquid, you could cook it longer, add less broth or use a slotted spoon when serving.
    

34. Brenda M says:

    You could probably add cream of mushroom soup to this. Looks yummy thanks for sharing!

35. Darlene Prevish says:

    I just cooked the liquid off, but I added garlic powder to it so the taste of the steak sauce wouldn't be so overpowering and I used a little less steak sauce. I'm going to try the teriyaki idea next time. Great recipe.

36. jake says:

    I have used white american cheese instead of provolone... i have been making philly cheese all along with it

37. Angie Bowers says:

    I tried this recipe exactly as is and it was DELISH!! AWESOME ??

38. Rene says:

    I made these last night. Very easy & very yummy. Whole family loved them. Will make again.

39. Kim says:

    I am making this tonight for dinner but going to cut down on mushrooms and bell peppers.Me and my oldest are the only ones who like mushrooms but I love bell peppers but no one else does.I am making up a pasta side to go with it.Hopeing it turns out to be really good.

40. Jeanene D says:

    Made this for dinner tonight. Everyone loved it. Used mozzarella instead of provolone cause that's what I had. Even my picky son liked it. Added some garlic. Only had bold and spicy A1 so used less and added in some soy sauce for flavor. Thanks for sharing!!! Will be going in the family likes it cookbook. :D

41. Jennifer says:

    Made this exactly as recipe states and my meat was soupy as well. I ended up draining liquid off and cooking it down. I would cut the broth amount at least in half. I wonder why you've never had that problem? Still yummy though! Easy way to have a philly!

42. Theresa says:

    I made this last night for my family and it was absolutely Delicious. Thank you for sharing :) I did add a tablespoon more of the A1 sauce and reduced the beef both in the pan till most of it reduced down 90%....yummy!!! We got bored of sloppy joe's years ago and this is our replacement now and oh my this is WAY better :)

43. Rachel says:

    Making this for dinner for tonight! This looks so good and we love philly cheesesteak! This will be a nice change from regular sloppy joes. I am not using mushrooms in it this time but I bet they would be very good!

44. Tammy says:

    My family absolutely love this recipe!!! The only thing I do differently is tha I leave out the mushrooms. Thank you so much for great recipes!!

45. Sarah Eades says:

    This was super delicious! I am not a steak sauce person, and I loved it. My picky daughter, who will not touch regular sloppy joes, ate this and liked it. Thanks for another good recipe to add to my rotation.

46. Tammie Abshire says:

    Made this for dinner tonight. It is YUMMY. Tastes like an original Philly. RECOMMENDED

47. Candee says:

    I made this tonight for dinner and it was absolutely delicious. We are trying to watch our carb intake so we used lettuce to wrap the filling instead of a bun and it was wonderful. I will be making this again for sure and it was so quick and easy. Love it !!!!!

48. Jacki Peketz says:

    My husband is a very sturdy guy who isn't really the gourmet type. He eats kind of like a picky three year old. He absolutely loved these. I caught him browsing your recipe page on his own today. Thank you for saving me from eating grilled cheese and beef jerky every night for the rest of my life. You girls are awesome!

49. John Chester says:

    I made this tonight. YUM-A-NUMMA!!!I used everything but the steak sauce (didn't have it & didn't miss it).I just cooked everything in a cast-iron skillet as directed, turned off the heat, put white American cheese on it & covered it 'til the cheese melted (just like I do with my regular Phillys).Put it on standard burger buns with a light spread of mayo (like I do with my regular Phillys).AWESOME!!! Tasted like a Philly but SO much easier!I may try a better bread, next time... It's SO totally worth it!!!

50. Katie Roberts says:

    These are my favourite ever! So comforting and savoury. Very easy for a quick meal as well. I've shared it with a few people now and they all love it.

51. Kim says:

    My family had seconds. Loved it! Easy to make

    

52. Arlene Unvoas says:

    I made this for our supper tonight and it’s really good. Thanks for sharing this “different” way to make sloppy Joes.

53. Leslie Johnson says:

    Do you think these would freeze Was thinking about making them with the Hawaiian rolls

54. Momma Cyd says:

    You just don't want the liquid to make the sliders soggy before the are frozen. Let us know how it turns out. You can always make the meat mixture and freeze that. Thaw when ready to make the sliders.